Valuation Allowances for Deferred Tax Assets

11.4 Valuation Allowances for Deferred Tax Assets

In the realm of accounting for income taxes, deferred tax assets (DTAs) play a crucial role in reflecting the future tax benefits attributable to deductible temporary differences, carryforwards, and tax credits. However, the realization of these assets is not always guaranteed. This section delves into the concept of valuation allowances for deferred tax assets, focusing on the assessment of realizability, recognition criteria, and practical examples relevant to the Canadian accounting profession.

Understanding Deferred Tax Assets

Deferred tax assets arise when there are deductible temporary differences between the tax base of an asset or liability and its carrying amount in the financial statements. They also occur due to unused tax losses and credits that can be carried forward to reduce future taxable income. DTAs are recognized on the balance sheet to reflect the anticipated reduction in future tax payments.

Key Sources of Deferred Tax Assets

1. Deductible Temporary Differences: These occur when the tax base of an asset or liability is higher than its carrying amount in the financial statements. For example, warranty expenses that are recognized for accounting purposes but not yet deductible for tax purposes create a deferred tax asset.

2. Tax Loss Carryforwards: When a company incurs a tax loss, it can carry forward the loss to offset taxable income in future periods, resulting in a deferred tax asset.

3. Tax Credit Carryforwards: Similar to loss carryforwards, unused tax credits can be carried forward to reduce future tax liabilities.

The Need for Valuation Allowances

While deferred tax assets represent potential future tax savings, their realization depends on the company’s ability to generate sufficient taxable income in the future. If it is more likely than not that some or all of the deferred tax assets will not be realized, a valuation allowance must be established.

Criteria for Recognizing a Valuation Allowance

The recognition of a valuation allowance is guided by the principle of conservatism in accounting. A valuation allowance is necessary when there is significant uncertainty regarding the realization of deferred tax assets. The key criteria include:

• Historical Financial Performance: Consistent losses in recent years may indicate that future taxable income will not be sufficient to utilize the deferred tax assets.
• Future Taxable Income Projections: Companies must assess whether future taxable income will be adequate to realize the deferred tax assets.
• Tax Planning Strategies: Consideration of feasible tax planning strategies that could enable the realization of deferred tax assets.
• Industry and Economic Conditions: Adverse industry trends or economic conditions that could impact future profitability.

Assessing the Realizability of Deferred Tax Assets

The assessment of realizability involves a comprehensive evaluation of both positive and negative evidence. Positive evidence includes future taxable income projections, existing contracts or sales backlogs, and tax planning strategies. Negative evidence encompasses historical losses, expiring carryforwards, and adverse economic conditions.

Steps in Assessing Realizability

1. Gathering Evidence: Collect all relevant evidence that supports or contradicts the realization of deferred tax assets.
2. Evaluating Evidence: Weigh the positive and negative evidence to determine the likelihood of realizing the deferred tax assets.
3. Documenting the Assessment: Maintain thorough documentation of the assessment process, including the evidence considered and the rationale for the conclusions reached.

Recognition and Measurement of Valuation Allowances

Once the assessment indicates that it is more likely than not that some or all of the deferred tax assets will not be realized, a valuation allowance must be recognized. The allowance is measured as the amount by which it is more likely than not that the deferred tax assets will not be realized.

Accounting for Valuation Allowances

• Initial Recognition: Record the valuation allowance as a reduction of the deferred tax asset on the balance sheet, with a corresponding charge to income tax expense in the income statement.
• Subsequent Adjustments: Reassess the valuation allowance at each reporting period. Adjustments to the allowance should reflect changes in the assessment of realizability.

Practical Examples and Case Studies

Example 1: A Manufacturing Company with Historical Losses

Consider a manufacturing company that has incurred significant losses over the past three years due to declining demand in its primary market. The company has deferred tax assets related to tax loss carryforwards. In assessing the realizability of these assets, the company must consider:

• Historical Losses: The consistent losses suggest a valuation allowance may be necessary.
• Future Projections: If the company anticipates a market recovery and has secured new contracts, this positive evidence could offset the historical losses.
• Tax Planning: The company could explore tax planning strategies, such as restructuring operations, to enhance future profitability.

Example 2: A Technology Firm with Expiring Tax Credits

A technology firm has deferred tax assets from unused tax credits that are set to expire in the next two years. The firm must evaluate:

• Current Profitability: If the firm is currently profitable and expects continued growth, it may realize the tax credits before they expire.
• Industry Trends: Rapid technological advancements and increased demand for the firm’s products could support the realization of the deferred tax assets.
• Valuation Allowance: If the firm determines that it is more likely than not that the credits will expire unused, a valuation allowance should be recorded.

Real-World Applications and Regulatory Scenarios

In Canada, the recognition and measurement of deferred tax assets and valuation allowances are governed by International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) as adopted in Canada, and Accounting Standards for Private Enterprises (ASPE) for private companies. Key standards include:

• IAS 12 Income Taxes: Provides guidance on the recognition and measurement of deferred tax assets and liabilities under IFRS.
• ASPE Section 3465 Income Taxes: Outlines the requirements for accounting for income taxes for private enterprises in Canada.

Compliance Considerations

• Disclosure Requirements: Companies must disclose the nature of the evidence supporting the recognition of deferred tax assets and any valuation allowances in the financial statements.
• Regulatory Scrutiny: Tax authorities and regulators may scrutinize the assumptions and evidence used in assessing the realizability of deferred tax assets.

Best Practices and Common Pitfalls

Best Practices

• Regular Reassessment: Continuously reassess the realizability of deferred tax assets and adjust valuation allowances as necessary.
• Comprehensive Documentation: Maintain detailed documentation of the evidence considered and the rationale for recognizing or adjusting valuation allowances.
• Engage Tax Experts: Collaborate with tax professionals to develop robust tax planning strategies that enhance the realization of deferred tax assets.

Common Pitfalls

• Overreliance on Historical Losses: Failing to consider positive evidence, such as future taxable income projections, can lead to unnecessary valuation allowances.
• Inadequate Documentation: Insufficient documentation of the assessment process can result in challenges during audits or regulatory reviews.

Strategies for Exam Success

• Understand Key Concepts: Familiarize yourself with the criteria for recognizing valuation allowances and the assessment of realizability.
• Practice with Examples: Work through practical examples and case studies to reinforce your understanding of the concepts.
• Stay Informed: Keep up-to-date with changes in accounting standards and tax regulations that impact deferred tax assets and valuation allowances.

Summary

Valuation allowances for deferred tax assets are a critical aspect of accounting for income taxes, requiring careful assessment of the realizability of these assets. By understanding the criteria for recognition, evaluating positive and negative evidence, and maintaining comprehensive documentation, companies can ensure accurate financial reporting and compliance with Canadian accounting standards.

Ready to Test Your Knowledge?